MLM jet merging

1. Event input source
2. Jet Matching parameters
3. Alpgen-specific parameters
4. Madgraph-specific parameters
5. Alpgen-style parton-jet merging
6. Madgraph-style parton-jet merging
7. A note on combining UserHooks

We also allow for two alternative sources of external events, one in the ALPGEN native format and one in the Madgraph LHEF-based one. All four combinations of input format and scheme are implemented. In the following it is therefore important to keep the two aspects apart, whenever the ALPGEN and Madgraph labels are used.

Currently all the files of interest are located in the include/Pythia8Plugins/ subdirectory:

• JetMatching.h contains the machinery for the parton-jet matching, in the two JetMatchingAlpgen and JetMatchingMadgraph classes.
• GeneratorInput.h contains three classes for the reading of ALPGEN event and parameter files, and one for the reading of Madgraph parameters.
• CombineMatchingInput.h contains three classes that combine the reading of events with the merging of them.
• main163.cc, main163.cmnd : a sample main program and card file showing the usage of the previous files/classes.

Event input source

Commonly, the source of external partons also contains information about how a particular type of algorithm should be employed. This information is handled by the AlpgenPar class for ALPGEN files, and MadgraphPar for LHEFs. The user can choose to set default merging parameters using the Alpgen:setMLM flag for ALPGEN files. For LHEFs, instead, the setting of default parameters is controlled with the JetMatching:setMad flag:

flag  JetMatching:setMad   (default = on)
When enabled, the merging parameters are set according to the values in the LHEF header. Specifically, the header must set the ickkw, xqcut, maxjetflavor and alpsfact values, and ickkw must be nonzero. Note that these labels are Madgraph-specific. For other programs with LHEF output, or for Madgraph files lacking this information, these parameters should be set by the user (or one can rely on the default values). The following parameters (described below) must then be specified:

• JetMatching:doMerge = ickkw,
• JetMatching:qCut = xqcut,
• JetMatching:nQmatch = maxjetflavor,
• JetMatching:clFact = alpsfact.

Jet Matching parameters

Scheme and Usage

flag  JetMatching:merge   (default = off)
Master switch to activate parton-jet matching. When off, all external events are accepted (unless they are rejected due to weighting or event processing problems).

mode  JetMatching:scheme   (default = 1; minimum = 1; maximum = 2)
The parton-jet MLM-style merging scheme.
option 1 : The one inspired by the Madgraph scheme, here implemented in the JetMatchingMadgraph class.
option 2 : The one inspired by the ALPGEN scheme, here implemented in the JetMatchingAlpgen class.

Jet algorithm

mode  JetMatching:jetAlgorithm   (default = 1; minimum = 1; maximum = 2)
The choice of jet algorithm to use when merging against hard partons. Currently, only SlowJet with the k_T algorithm (and useStandardR = false) is supported for Madgraph-style merging, while there is full freedom for the ALPGEN-style merging.
option 1 : The CellJet cone algorithm.
option 2 : The SlowJet clustering algorithm.

mode  JetMatching:slowJetPower   (default = -1; minimum = -1; maximum = 1)
The power to use in the SlowJet algorithm.
option -1 : The anti-k_T algorithm.
option 0 : The Cambridge/Aachen algorithm.
option 1 : The k_T algorithm.

mode  JetMatching:nEta   (default = 100; minimum = 50)
Specific to the CellJet algorithm, the number of bins in pseudorapidity.

mode  JetMatching:nPhi   (default = 60; minimum = 30)
Specific to the CellJet algorithm, the number of bins in phi.

parm  JetMatching:eTseed   (default = 1.5; minimum = 0.0)
Specific to the CellJet algorithm, the minimum eT for a cell to be acceptable as the trial center of a jet.

parm  JetMatching:eTthreshold   (default = 0.1)
Specific to the CellJet algorithm, cells with eT < eTthreshold are completely neglected by the jet algorithm.

Merging parameters

parm  JetMatching:eTjetMin   (default = 20.0; minimum = 5.0)
For the CellJet algorithm, this gives the minimum transverse energy inside a cone for a jet to be accepted. For the SlowJet algorithm, this is instead the minimum transverse momentum required for a cluster to be accepted as a jet. For the Madgraph scheme, this parameter should match the qCut parameter described later.

parm  JetMatching:coneRadius   (default = 0.7; minimum = 0.1)
For the CellJet algorithm, this gives the size of the cone in (eta, phi) space drawn around the geometric center of the jet. For the SlowJet algorithm, this gives the R parameter.

parm  JetMatching:etaJetMax   (default = 2.5; minimum = 0.1)
For both jet algorithms, this defines the maximum pseudorapidity that the detector is assumed to cover. In this context, however, it is tied to the phase space region in which partons have been generated. For the Alpgen scheme, particles within etaJetMax + coneRadius are passed to the jet algorithm, with only jets within etaJetMax retained in the merging. For the Madgraph scheme, only particles within etaJetMax are used.

Exclusive mode

mode  JetMatching:exclusive   (default = 2; minimum = 0; maximum = 2)
Exclusive or inclusive merging.
option 0 : The merging is run in inclusive mode. All partons must match jets, but additional jets are allowed, provided they are not harder than the matched jets.
option 1 : The merging is run in exclusive mode. All partons must match jets, and no additional jets are allowed.
option 2 : If nJet < nJetMax, then the merging is run in exclusive mode, otherwise it is run in inclusive mode. For the Madgraph scheme, this is checked on an event-by-event basis, which is useful when an LHEF contains a "soup" of partonic multiplicities. If nJetMax < 0 or nJet < 0, then the algorithm defaults to exclusive mode.

mode  JetMatching:nJet   (default = -1; minimum = -1)
When JetMatching:exclusive = 2, nJet indicates the minimum number of additional light jets in the incoming process. This value may be set automatically.

mode  JetMatching:nJetMax   (default = -1; minimum = -1)
When JetMatching:exclusive = 2, nJetMax is used to indicate the maximum number of jets that will be matched.

Jet matching

mode  JetMatching:jetAllow   (default = 1; minimum = 1; maximum = 2)
Controls which particles are clustered by the jet algorithm.
option 1 : This option explicitly disallows top quarks, leptons and photons. All other particle types are passed to the jet algorithm.
option 2 : No extra particles are disallowed.

Alpgen-specific parameters

mode  JetMatching:jetMatch   (default = 1; minimum = 1; maximum = 2)
Criteria for matching a clustered jet to a parton.
option 1 : This option can be used with both the CellJet and SlowJet algorithms. The delta R between each parton and jet is taken, and the minimal value compared against coneMatchLight * coneRadius for light jets or coneMatchHeavy * coneRadiusHeavy for heavy jets. Note that by default coneRadiusHeavy = coneRadius, see below. If below this value, the parton and jet are considered to match. With CellJet, the delta R measure is in (eta, phi), while with SlowJet it is in (y, phi).
option 2 : This option can only be used with the SlowJet algorithm. The hard partons are inserted into the parton level event as "ghost" particles, but at the correct (y, phi) position. If this particle is then clustered into a jet, it is considered a match.

parm  JetMatching:coneMatchLight   (default = 1.5; minimum = 0.1)
The coneMatchLight parameter used when JetMatching:jetMatch = 1.

parm  JetMatching:coneRadiusHeavy   (default = -1.0)
The coneRadiusHeavy parameter used when JetMatching:jetMatch = 1. When assigned a negative value, the value of JetMatching:coneRadius is used.

parm  JetMatching:coneMatchHeavy   (default = 1.0; minimum = 0.1)
The coneMatchHeavy parameter used when JetMatching:jetMatch = 1.

Madgraph-specific parameters

flag  JetMatching:doShowerKt   (default = off)
This switch changes the merging prescription to the shower-kT scheme outlined in [Alw08]. This scheme differs from "classical" MLM jet merging with respect to when the matching veto is checked. The shower-kT scheme considers already immediately after the first shower emission if an event should be discarded.

parm  JetMatching:qCut   (default = 10.0; minimum = 0.0)
k_T scale for merging shower products into jets.

mode  JetMatching:nQmatch   (default = 5; minimum = 3; maximum = 6)
Controls the treatment of heavy quarks.
option 5 : All quarks (except top) are treated as light quarks for matching.
option 4 : Bottom quarks are treated separately. Currently, they are unmatched.

parm  JetMatching:clFact   (default = 1.0)
The clFact parameter determines how jet-to parton matching is done. A match is defined as a squared cluster scale that equals:
|clFact| * qCut for inclusive mode,
|clFact| * max(qCut,min(p_T(parton))) for exclusive mode, clFact ≥ 0, or
|clFact| * min(k_T(parton)) for exclusive mode, clFact < 0.

flag  JetMatching:doVeto   (default = on)
If turned off, then no jet matching veto will be applied internally in Pythia. Instead, it is assumed that the (expert) user enforces all necessary vetoes externally by some other means. Do not change the default value unless you are an expert in MLM jet matching and want to use your own code to perform the necessary vetoes.

An implementation of the FxFx prescription for combining multiple NLO calculations [Fre12] and its updated treatment of non-enhanced jets as described in [Fre21] is available. FxFx merging with aMC@NLO shares most parameters with the leading-order (MadGraph-style) MLM prescriptions and can be activated by using the three additional settings below.

flag  JetMatching:doFxFx   (default = off)
If turned on, then FxFx merging with aMC@NLO inputs is performed. Note that this requires event samples that are specifically generated for this task.

mode  JetMatching:nPartonsNow   (default = -1)
The number of partons in Born-like events for the current input LHEF. If the current sample e.g. contains pp → e+e- + 2 partons Born-like configurations, and pp → e+e- + 3 partons Real-emission-type events, then JetMatching:nPartonsNow = 2 applies.

parm  JetMatching:qCutME   (default = 10.0)
The cut applied to regulate multi-jet matrix elements. Note that this cut can differ from the matching scale.

Alpgen-style parton-jet merging

First, either the CellJet or SlowJet jet algorithm is chosen. Both of these algorithms have an R and an etaMax parameter. In addition, CellJet has an eTmin and SlowJet has a pTmin parameter. These are the primary three parameters of the merging procedure, and in practice are set dependent on the cuts applied to the matrix element (ME) generation. We stress that the merging procedure is not tied to the geometry of a specific physical detector, but only to the match between the original partons and the resulting jets, using standard jet algorithms in the phase space region where partons have been generated.

ME samples with different jet multiplicities are run through the event generator, and the generation interrupted after parton showers have been applied, but before resonance decays and beam remnants have been processed. Note in particular that top quarks will not yet be decayed, which may lead to slight differences with the PYTHIA 6 interface included with the ALPGEN package. In what follows, the hardness measure of jets/partons is taken to be eT when CellJet is used and pT when SlowJet is used. The hard system (ignoring all MPI systems) is then analysed:

• The particles in the original matrix element process are sorted into light partons, heavy partons and other particles. For backwards compatibility, a light parton is defined as the set (d, u, s, c, b, g) with zero mass. A heavy parton is defined as the set (c, b, t) with non-zero mass.
• All particles not originating from the heavy partons or other particles are passed to the jet algorithm and clustered.
• Clustered jets are matched to the light partons in the original ME process. There are two different methods which can be used:
  • Method 1: The following is done for each parton, in order of decreasing hardness. The delta R between the parton and all jets is calculated and the smallest value taken. If this is less than the jet R parameter, possibly multiplied by a constant, the jet and parton are considered to match, and the jet is removed from further consideration. Note that for CellJet the delta R measure is in (eta, phi), while for SlowJet, it is in (y, phi).
  • Method 2: This method is only possible when using the SlowJet algorithm. Before the clustering is performed, extremely soft "ghost" particles are added to the event at the (y, phi) coordinates of the original matrix element partons. If such a particle is clustered into a jet, the parton and jet are considered to match. The idea of "ghost" particles was originally introduced by FastJet as a way to measure jet areas [Cac06] and should not affect clustering with an infrared-safe jet algorithm.
• If there is a light ME parton remaining which has not been matched to a jet, then the event is vetoed. If all ME partons have been matched to a jet, but there are still some extra jets remaining, then two options are possible:
  • Exclusive mode: the event is vetoed. This is typically used when there are ME samples with higher jet multiplicities, which would fill in the extra jets.
  • Inclusive mode: the event is retained if the extra jets are softer than the softest matched jet. This is typically used when there is no ME sample with higher jet multiplicity, so the parton shower should be allowed to give extra jets.
• All particles originating from the heavy partons are passed to the jet algorithm and clustered.
• The clustered jets are again matched to the original partons, but there is no requirement for a match to be present; all matched jets are immediately discarded. The matching procedure is much the same as for light partons, but with two differences when delta R matching is used. First, a different R parameter than that used by the jet algorithm may optionally be given. Second, all jets that are within the given radius of the parton are matched, not just the one with the smallest delta R measure. If there are still extra jets remaining then in exclusive mode the event is immediately vetoed, while in inclusive mode the event is retained if the extra jets are softer than the softest light matched jet.

Some different options are provided, specified further above in the parameters section. These are set so that, by default, the algorithm closely follows the official MLM interface provided in the ALPGEN package.

All vetoing of events is done through the usual User Hooks machinery, and is therefore already taken into account in the cross section. In the output from Pythia::stat(), the difference between the "Selected" and "Accepted" columns gives the number of events that have not survived the vetoing procedure. It is still the responsibility of the user to add together the results from runs with different jet multiplicities. In the simplest case, when ALPGEN input is used and the hard process parameters are used to guide the merging procedure, it is enough to set the JetMatching:nJetMax parameter.

Madgraph-style parton-jet merging

This section describes the Madgraph parton-jet merging algorithm for PYTHIA8.

First, the k_T jet algorithm is applied using the PYTHIA8 SlowJet implementation. The useStandardR = false is used, ie. the (delta R)^2 separation is defined as 2 (cosh(delta y) - cos(delta phi)) rather than the more common (delta y)^2 + delta phi)^2. The R, etaMax, and a pTmin parameters are specified. By default, R = 1 and pTmin = qCut . It is not recommended to change these. These should match the algorithm parameters used in the Madgraph Matrix Element (ME) generation.

ME samples with different jet multiplicities are run through the event generator, and the generation is interrupted after parton showers have been applied, but before resonance decays and beam remnants have been processed. In what follows, the hardness measure of jets/partons is taken to be k_T relative to qCut. The hard system (ignoring all MPI systems) is analyzed:

• The hard partons in the original matrix element process, provided by the LHEF, are sorted into light partons, heavy partons and other particles. A heavy parton is defined by the JetMatching:nQmatch or by the maxjetflavor value in the LHEF. nQmatch refers to the absolute value of the quark PDG identity code.
• All partons arising from the parton shower are sorted based on their motherhood. A showered parton arising from a heavy parton or "other" parton classified in the previous step is not passed to the jet algorithm. All other partons are clustered into light jets.
• It is checked whether there are "too few" or "too many" light jets. If the number of light jets is less than the number of light partons defined by nQmatch, the event is vetoed. If the number is larger, the event is vetoed only in exclusive mode (defined below).
• In exclusive mode, the number of jets matches the number of light partons. In inclusive mode, the jets are re-clustered until the number of jets equals the number of light partons. Next, each light hard parton is clustered, one at a time, with the jets until a match is found. A match is defined as a squared cluster scale that equals:
  • |clFact| * qCut for inclusive mode,
  • |clFact| * max(qCut,min(p_T(parton))) for exclusive mode, clFact ≥ 0, or
  • |clFact| * min(k_T(parton)) for exclusive mode, clFact < 0.
  If no match is found, the event is vetoed. When a parton matches a jet, the jet is removed from the collection, and the process continues. The process terminates when all partons are matched to a jet, or a parton is unmatched.
• All particles originating from the heavy partons are not used.

Some different options are provided, specified further above. These are set so that, by default, the algorithm closely follows the FORTRAN interface ME2Pythia provided in the Madgraph package.

All vetoing of events is done through the usual User Hooks machinery, and is therefore already taken into account in the cross section. In the output from Pythia::stat(), the difference between the "Selected" and "Accepted" columns gives the number of events that have not survived the vetoing procedure. It is still the responsibility of the user to add together the results from runs with different jet multiplicities. In the simplest case, when the hard process parameters are used to guide the merging procedure, events will be matched in the exclusive mode.

Madgraph scheme with no internal vetoes (assuming an external veto implementation)

This section describes the facilities that allow expert users to use their own veto code to perform a Madgraph-style merging. This can e.g. be useful to assess parameter changes without having to process the same input events multiple times.

As a first step, any vetoes in the Pythia Jet Matching need to be disabled by using JetMatching:doVeto = off. In this mode, Pythia only stores all the information that is necessary to check (and apply) the shower-kT or kT-MLM vetoes externally by hand. This information can be accessed by calling the functions

Event JetMatchingMadgraph::getWorkEventJet()  
Return the event after parton showering, without resonance decay products and particles that should not be included in the jet matching, as necessary to implement the vetoes in the kT-MLM scheme.

Event JetMatchingMadgraph::getProcessSubset()  
Return the event record containing the hard process, without resonance decay products and particles that should not be included in the jet matching, as necessary to implement the vetoes in the shower-kT and kT-MLM schemes. In the former, this event is needed to find the lowest pT in the ME inputs. In the latter, the event record is used to count the number of hard-process partons, minimal hard process pT, and to perform the matching of hard-process particles to shower jets.

bool JetMatchingMadgraph::getExclusive()  
Return flag to identify if exclusive or inclusive vetoes should be applied to this event.

double JetMatchingMadgraph::getPTfirst()  
Return the transverse momentum (w.r.t. the beam) of the first parton shower emission, as needed for the shower-kT scheme.

vector <double> JetMatchingMadgraph::getDJR()  
Return a vector of jet clustering scales produced by running the jet algorithm used for jet matching on the event record without resonance decay products and particles that should not be included in the matching. In this vector, clustering scales for combining few jets appear before scales from combining many jets. This function is useful for the kT-MLM scheme, or to have quick access to this information for histogramming and sanity checks.

We do not currently supply example code for this very advanced functionality. Interested expert users should feel free to contact the Pythia authors for further explanations.

A note on combining UserHooks

One must then combine multiple UserHooks classes, such that the functionality of both is present. A prerequisite is that the different UserHooks classes should be declared with virtual inheritance, e.g.

 
  class JetMatching : virtual public UserHooks 

The two first classes in CombineMatchingInput.h combine ALPGEN input with the two different matching schemes, e.g. for the first

 
class JetMatchingAlpgenInputAlpgen : public AlpgenHooks, 
  public JetMatchingAlpgen { 
public: 
  // Constructor and destructor. 
  JetMatchingAlpgenInputAlpgen(Pythia& pythia) : AlpgenHooks(pythia), 
    JetMatchingAlpgen() { } 
  ~JetMatchingAlpgenInputAlpgen() {} 
  // Initialisation. 
  virtual bool initAfterBeams() { 
    if (!AlpgenHooks::initAfterBeams()) return false; 
    if (!JetMatchingAlpgen::initAfterBeams()) return false; 
    return true; 
  } 
  // Process level vetos. 
  virtual bool canVetoProcessLevel() { 
    return JetMatchingAlpgen::canVetoProcessLevel(); 
  } 
  .... 
};